In Arizona, there is simply no magic age at which a child gets to decide which parent they can live with when their parents divorce. Children are not able to simply choose which parent they want to live with under North Carolina law. She has told her told mother the same. There could be many issues affecting this – age, school, travel for visitation, location of the other parent, extra-curricular or other options available to the child with the other parent. Be prepared to present your entire case and convince the court, despite the child’s preference or including the child’s preference, the best interest of the child is to remain with your or begin living with the other parent. However, that is not to say your child will have the ability to decide whom to live with during a divorce. © 2021 Evans Law Group. There is no set age in Australia and it is a factor to be considered. This article examines all of the factors involved in deciding whether a child’s preference carries any importance with a family court judge. If you are someone you know are facing a situation involving child custody, contact the Evans Family Law Group today at (512) 628-2550 or email Mr. Evans directly at jimmy@evansflg.com. The typical scenario is that a couple divorce when their children are younger and the custody is awarded to the mother. What are the best apps for separated parents? Courts may take the child’s preference into consideration when making an order on parenting time. There is no simple, straight answer that anyone can give you; and if someone has given you a flat age, they either do not understand the complexity of this issue or have decided not to share those complexities with you. The test the Court applies when considering the opinions and wishes of your child is two fold: However the answer to the two-fold test is not a simple “yes” or “no” and is not a question of whether your child’s wishes will be considered or not. Let’s face it, a 13 year old is not always the be judge to make these kinds of life altering determinations – despite their insistence they know everything. But, their choice does not mean a change in residence is imminent. Tips on negotiating a financial settlement. When the Child is Younger than 12. A child cannot legally “decide” which parent to live with; as seen above, there are numerous other factors to consider, and in many cases, the family law courts will make a decision based on what they believe to be in the best interest of the child. The Court does consider the wishes of the children in … Although the legislation does not define a minimum age, there are numerous reported case law that implies that a child’s wishes should “definitely be considered” at 12 years old according to Albers v Albers, 2011 ABQB 456. It is commonly misunderstood in Texas that a Child 12 years of age or older can “decide” with which parent they want to live. Let’s not forget that a 17 year-old can be tried as an adult for a crime without the need of a juvenile waiver or designated proceedings. They also may think that the parent is trying to manipulate the child into picking them. This question potentially comes with the most ‘lawyer’ answer you will receive: it depends. Court Orders. The laws vary from state to state as it relates to whether a child has a true right to choose which parent they want to live with. If you find yourself in a modification suit where the Court will likely interview your child in this regard, you must conduct yourself very, very, carefully as the Court’s are very savvy and can see through situations in which a parent is manipulating or acting inappropriately in this regard. An attorney can submit details of the child’s wishes as a motion to the court. However, children under 18 cannot unilaterally pick the parent that they want to live with. There is no defined age in Alberta or in British Columbia at which children can choose where to live when their parents are separated. The bad parents would always bribe and promise trying to get their way. It happens too much now as it is. After a judge decided that the 12-year-old would engage in the same child custody arrangement as the triplets, the child indicated that she no longer wanted to spend overnights with her father, who lived in … Usually, this is accomplished by the court bringing it’s court reporter into chambers to transcribe the interview with the Child. when can children decide which parent to live with? And, as you may be experiencing in your own situation, it’s sometimes hard to tell who is really pulling the strings – the children or the parents who are supposed to be parenting their children. However, for a child 12 years of age or older, an interview is mandatory. Finalising your financial separation sooner rather than later, Tips to reduce the emotional and legal costs of divorce and separation. Worried about child getting taken overseas – Airport Watch List, How to avoid court – Alternative Dispute Resolution, What to do if family law orders aren’t followed – Breach of family law orders. Mothers and Fathers rights to see their child, Suite 34, Aspley Hypermarket, Albany Creek Road, Aspley, Brisbane, Westfield CHERMSIDE Level 2, Gympie Rd, Chermside QLD 4032, 30 Chancellor Village Boulevard Sippy Downs Queensland 4556, Toowong Tower, Level 5/9 Sherwood Rd, Toowong QLD 4066. best to discuss your matter with a solicitor to receive legal advice specific to your circumstances. What am I entitled to in a divorce or separation in Australia? The age at which your child can decide who they live with, who they spend time with and how much time they spend with that parent (if any) is dependent on a number of factors. This only becomes an issue with primary conservatorship is an issue in the case. Should you finalise your financial separation sooner rather than later? In Michigan, a sixteen-year old can even get married with parental consent. In the recent past, there was a provision in the law that any child 12 years of age or older could sign a form known as a “designation of preference” to live with the parent named in the designation. The Child's Preference in Custody Cases. How much weight their preference is given by the judge is totally up to the judge. How does domestic violence affect child custody? They appear to be uniformly surprised to learn that a minor child does not have the legal right to decide which parent to live with. There are many, many, many factors that may come into play when this occurs. Texas does not allow children to choose where to live at any age. What do you have to tell the otherside in a family law matter? As a result, it is not accurate to say that when a child reaches 12 years old they will have the right to choose which parent to live with. This magical age is usually believed to be 12, 13, or 14. A child’s desire in which parent to reside is one of many factors the Court will consider. He is a skilled negotiator and strategist and fights zealously for his clients family law rights. She has even gone as far as saying she’s going to run away or not get on an airplane when she’s supposed to go with her mother. The Family Code provides that the court shall interview in chambers a child 12 years of age or older to determine the child’s wishes as to conservatorship or as to the person who shall have the exclusive right to determine the child’s primary residence. What if your child is sick and the other parent can’t look after them? What about debts that happen after separation? Reasonable Doubt: Debunking myths: “At 12 years old, my child can choose which parent to live with” by Laurel Dietz on April 18th, 2014 at 9:00 AM 1 of 1 2 of 1 Public policy in Texas is to: (1) assure that children have frequent and continuing contact with parents who have shown the ability to act in the best interest of the child; and (2) provide a safe, stable, and nonviolent environment for … How does the family court treat assets and debts incurred after separation? Child Support Agreements Binding vs Limited. The court will apply a gradient to your child’s wishes and preferences and, depending on their age and level of maturity, your child’s decision may have a significant impact on the outcome of your legal proceedings, or it may be balanced against other factors outlined in the Family Law Act which the Court must give consideration to (including the importance of maintaining a significant relationship with both parents, and the need to protect the child from child abuse and family violence). After the age of 12, however, the court may consider the child’s wishes in conjunction with other factors. The short answer is that children can make their own decisions about where they will reside once they reach the age of majority, which is 18 in Canada. One of the most common mis-perceptions about Texas law is that once a child turns 12, he or she can decide where he or she will live, meaning the child can decide who has custody. I would ask all parents out there to think about how many major decisions a 12-year-old gets to make alone and have the decisions bind his/her parents. In Arizona, there is simply no magic age at which a child gets to decide which parent they can live with when their parents divorce. Despite this, your child’s wishes can be considered by the court no matter how old they are. As a family law lawyer, I am frequently asked this question. Understanding Divorce Costs: a Quick Guide, POPULAR NOW: Child Custody for This School Year, Client’s First Meeting With An Austin Child Custody Attorney, James Evans: Austin Divorce Attorney & Family Attorney. Since this child only has one surviving parent, then, the child is going to be with that parent. In my country, the law is, that at 12, the child's opinion has to be noted and listened to in divorce cases, but it should never be left to a child to choose between their parents. If mediation fails do I have to go to court? Most fourteen year olds are mature enough to make good witnesses. This question potentially comes with the most ‘lawyer’ answer you will receive: it depends. Are assets received post family law separation included in the property settlement? This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. For legal counsel to help do what’s best for your children, for you, and for your family as a whole, contact Evans Law Group in Austin today. A judge may also take into account the child’s own wishes. The court is always required to consider the entirety of the circumstances, what circumstances have changed since the rendition of the prior order of the Court, and whether or not in the opinion not the Court that the Child’s desires are in fact in the best interest of that Child. Attorneys often hear from clients that they have heard from relatives or friends that a child can choose where they want to live when they reach a certain age. The parent who is not selected by the child could still change that outcome if he or she can prove to the court that the selected parent would not be able to provide for the child or is otherwise not a choice that is in the child’s best interest. Questions regarding if a child or teenager can decide which parent to live with. What happens if a BFA isn’t done properly? Therefore, if you are faced with a modification suit in which the child may be interviewed, you and your attorney should not rely solely upon the desires of the child. In this regard the Court is assisted by a family consultant (generally. What to do when a parent takes a child without permission and won’t return them. There is a common misconception that in Family Law parenting disputes about with whom a child will live, a child will have the deciding vote when they reach the age of 12. ... An infant would not be able to provide testimony, and the testimony of a 6 year old may not be as relevant as the testimony of a 17 year old (who is still a minor until they turn 18). There are many, many, many factors that may come into play when this occurs. It is all too common that after a final decree of divorce or custody, that at some point in time a child starts expressing their clear desire to live with the other parent on a primary basis. It can be heartbreaking to hear your teen say they want to live with their other parent. I am grateful that a 12 year old or really any minor under the age of 18 can’t choose which parent to live with. The old Texas statute stated that a child 12 years of age or older could file with the Court in writing the name of the parent who the child would choose to have the right to determine where they lived, subject to the approval of the court. In other circumstances a 13 or 14 year old’s wishes may be given significant weight if they are expressed in a well thought out and mature manner. Published March 24, 2015 . ... Can younger children decide where they want to live? The mere age of your child will not determine your family law matter. That being said, a child’s wishes can be taken into consideration by a judge during a custody trial. Judges consider a number of factors before changing a custody order. Learn more here. Courts may take the child’s preference into consideration when making an order on parenting time. I have personally been in situations where all the way up to the interview the child was expressing her desire to live with my client and changed her mind on the day of the interview. If the child is 12 years old or older, the Court is required upon a request by any of the parties to the suit to make a record of the interview with the Child. This DID NOT mean that they could choose which parent they wanted to live with. A child need not be at this magic number, but generally it is a good number. You should thoroughly discuss this with your attorney and carefully set forth a strategy for conducting yourself and in the presence of the Child prior to the interview occurring. However, the weight a Court places on the child’s preference will depend on the child’s maturity and age. That would be terribly unfair to ask a child. Although the legislation does not define a minimum age, there are numerous reported case law that implies that a child’s wishes should “definitely be considered” at 12 years old according to Albers v Albers, 2011 ABQB 456. which parent do they want to live with). Contrary to popular belief, there is no golden age at which a child’s views will be determinative. Another prominent legal myth is that a 16 years can decide with which parent they are going to live. Many children and parents often wonder at what age a child can decide their own custody/ living arrangements.. The courts will still consider the best interests of the child before making any modifications. A judge may ask a child who is old enough (typically 12 to 14) which parent he or she prefers to live with the majority of the time. All rights reserved. In this case, one of the first questions parents ask when it comes custody is whether the court will allow the child to choose which parent to live with. There will come a time where a child is able to ‘vote with their feet’ so to speak and place themselves physically where they want to be. A child as young as 10 years old can at times have a voice as well according to RM vs JS, 2013 ABCA 441. In most instances, South Carolina is not going to allow children under the age of 12 to voice their preference about which parent they would like to live with. Can Your 12-year-old Decide Which Parent to Live/Visit With? Can a 12-Year-Old Child Decide Which Parent to Live With? Therefore, it is difficult to overcome a 14 year old … However, in 2009, the Texas legislature repealed this provision in the law due to many policy reasons – mostly the obvious of why having children sign off on such a form causes significant issues between the parties and their child or children. Your child's request to live with your ex doesn’t have to be seen as a negative evaluation of who you are as a person or a parent. What if the other parent won’t return my child? The purpose of the interview, as stated in the family code, is to allow the Court to discuss with the child:  (1) the child’s desires with regard to residency and primary conservatorship, (2) visitation, or (3) any other issues which are involved in the underlying custody suit. Child Recovery Orders. If the parents are in agreement on primary conservatorship, an interview with the Child is not allowed. This form would be filed with the Court and become the basis for a suit to modify the previous custody order and seek a change in primary conservatorship. Thankfully I got lucky and had a great lawyer & … The child’s “decision” or opinions are not, however, binding on the Court. If so, what if the parent that child chooses is - Answered by a verified Family Lawyer When your child turns 12, can they decide which parent to live with? Remember, the court is always required to consider the entirety of the circumstances, what circumstances have changed since the rendition of the prior order of the Court, and whether or not in the opinion not the Court that the Child’s desires are in fact in the best interest of that Child. Can a 16-year-old decide which parent he wants to live with? At any age. The age at which your child can decide where they live and how much time they spend with the other parent is subjective, meaning it will vary from child to child. This is not the case. This interview is conducted “in chambers”, or in the Judge’s private office or other private setting of the Judge’s choosing. Do Grandparents have rights in family law? A child as young as 10 years old can at times have a voice as well according to RM vs JS, 2013 ABCA 441. So, the child’s preference – even if not in your favor – is not the end of the Story. Despite this, your child’s wishes can be considered by the court no matter how old they are. This misunderstanding causes a lot of litigation and stress between parents and their children. In other word’s, the child’s reasons for their decision were not deemed mature and appropriate. Texas family code accounts for a child’s opinion no matter the age. If an older child such as a 15, 16 or 17 year-old has a preference and that opinion is expressed to the Judge, Court Investigator or Guardian ad Litem than the judge will usually respect the child’s desire. How to save on legal costs in a family law matter. Many states have started to consider a child’s stated preference for the parent with whom the child wishes to reside when the child reaches 12 or 13. In fact, laws vary widely from state to state. This article is designed to give you a very a brief overview of the law in the State of Texas on how a child, under these circumstances, can express their preference and have their opinion heard by the Court. He tells her that the law states that she can choose, now that she is 12.There are many reasons that this is a bad idea but bottom line is, she does not want to. Can a twelve, (12), year old child decide which parent to reside with? A child’s preference can be most effective when both parents are equally “fit,” all living conditions for the child are relatively equal, and the child is fourteen (14) years of age or over. The age at which your child can decide who they live with, who they spend time with and how much time they spend with that parent (if any) is dependent on a number of factors. ... Can younger children decide where they want to live? If an older child such as a 15, 16 or 17 year-old has a preference and that opinion is expressed to the Judge, Court Investigator or Guardian ad Litem than the judge will usually respect the child’s desire. Can a binding financial agreement be overturned? Instead, the Texas Legislature left in the law a provision which allows the Court to conduct an interview with the child to determine that child’s wishes. If you’re having a hard time viewing your child's request objectively, talk with a friend or counselor about how you can separate your child’s request from your identity as a parent. After a judge decided that the 12-year-old would engage in the same child custody arrangement as the triplets, the child indicated that she no longer wanted to spend overnights with … The laws governing a child and his or her right to choose which parent with whom to reside are far from settled. How much does it cost to draft a consent order? Divorce Divorced Parents: Kids Should Decide Where They Live/Custody Divorce can be ugly, but it doesn't have to be ugly for the kids. The only exceptions to this that come to mine are: (1) if the father agrees to the entry of an order giving custody to the grandparents or (2) if the grandparents take the father to court and convince the court that the father is an unfit parent. This is an opportunity which must be carefully considered and thought through, because we all know children can be fickle under these circumstances. Once a child reaches the age of 16, he/she is legally allowed to choose which parent to live with. Principal Family Lawyer at Cudmore Legal Family Lawyers Brisbane Co. Luke is experienced in family law matters ranging from divorce to child custody. Posted Nov 02, 2012 How are loans and gifts considered in family law? What happens if I wait to long to do a settlement? Can your child’s particular health condition – impact your child custody arrangements? Every child is different and every child grows and develops at their own pace. What Texas law provides, however, is a method by which a Child over 12 years of age may have their wishes, desires, or opinions known with regard to residency and primary conservatorship (i.e. When can a child choose which parent they want to live with, in Australia? How long do I have to do a property settlement? Rather, the question for determination is: what weight will the court give to your child’s wishes? Can a 15 year old choose which parent to live with? As a result, a child custody agreement can require modification based on a child’s desire to live with one parent over the other. There is no defined age in Alberta or in British Columbia at which children can choose where to live when their parents are separated. No. As for the 12-year-old, the issue of parenting time could not be resolved and was deferred to the court. Split Custody Schedules. There have been cases before the Court where a 17 year old child’s wishes were given limited weight because the basis for this child’s decision was not balanced. In fact, Arizona has no “magic age” at which the children can choose their own parenting time schedule. ... Our 12 year old has on numerous occasions over the past 3 years said that she wants to live with me and not her mother. Divorce and custody battles can be especially difficult on children. The court may, but is not required to allow the attorneys for the parties, if there is an attorney representing the child (amicus attorney or attorney ad litem), or the child’s guardian to be present during the interview with the Child. If your child is expressing a wish for different parenting arrangements it is best to discuss your matter with a solicitor to receive legal advice specific to your circumstances. At what age can a child decide which parent to live with? However, a child can only make a custody selection once over a two-year period from the date of the last selection. As for the 12-year-old, the issue of parenting time could not be resolved and was deferred to the court. In this case, one of the first questions parents ask when it comes custody is whether the court will allow the child to choose which parent to live with. My 12 year old daughter's father, who has visitation but not custody, is pressuring her to live with he and his family. It is commonly misunderstood in Texas that a Child 12 years of age or older can “decide” with which parent they want to live. This misunderstanding causes a lot of litigation and stress between parents and their children. Can I negotiate my own property settlement? Can my child live with me if they want to? Most courts will see the child too young to make the decision. Can a parent get custody if they have a history of domestic violence? A child’s preference can be most effective when both parents are equally “fit,” all living conditions for the child are relatively equal, and the child is fourteen (14) years of age or over. The answer is more complicated that a straightforward “yes” or “no.” In South Carolina, there is no exact age when a child may choose to live with one parent or the other. At what age can a child decide which parent to live with? Our Austin Child Custody Attorneys are experienced in child custody suits and modification suits affecting child custody. Badmouth the other parent. The court will then weigh other factors and make a decision. by Hallier Lawrence | Apr 25, 2016 | Child Custody. However, the weight a Court places on the child’s preference will depend on the child’s maturity and age. In effect, children can “choose” which parent to live with if all involved decision makers — that is, the significant adults in the child’s life — are in agreement about the child’s future living arrangements and that agreement meshes with the child’s own wishes. Parents of divorced or separated parents often want to know when their children can decide where they want to live. Generally if a child is over the age of 12 and is thought to understand the situation, their wishes can influence the outcome. What about assets received post-separation? The Court will still consider the evidence in the case – such as the opinions of the Child’s therapist or counselor, teachers, friends and neighbors and other family members along with many, many other factors. NO! What about debts incurred post-separation? If not carefully monitored, this can be abused by parents as they relate to their children going forward after divorce or a final custody order has been rendered by the Court. For a child under 12 years of age, the interview is discretionary with the Court. Discretionary with the most ‘ lawyer ’ answer you will receive: it.. Consider a number of factors before changing a custody order preference is given by the.... That would be terribly unfair to ask a child ’ s wishes before making any modifications in a law! History of domestic violence grows and develops at their own parenting time their. The courts will see the child ’ s wishes in conjunction with other factors and make a custody selection over! A 15 year old choose which parent they want to live with stress between parents and their children younger... Of many factors that may come into play when this occurs belief, there is no age. Making any modifications golden age at which a child under 12 years age. And strategist and fights zealously for his clients family law matter age in Alberta in! Parent that they want to live custody if they want to live any! Are experienced in child custody arrangements be especially difficult on children child is not to your... Permission and won ’ t done properly wonder at what age can a child only... To get their way child need not be resolved and was deferred to the judge is totally to. Will depend on the child ’ s wishes any age sixteen-year old can even get married with parental.... Into picking them governing a child 12 years of age or older, an interview with most. And his or her right to choose which parent do they want to live with fights zealously for his family... Their parents are in agreement on primary conservatorship, an interview is mandatory and child. You will receive: it depends be especially difficult on children old can even get with! Considered in family law matters ranging from divorce to child custody many children and parents often at... Issue with primary conservatorship, an interview with the court this occurs an attorney submit. Parent won ’ t look after them involved in deciding whether a child 12 years of age, child... To manipulate the child ’ s wishes can be considered by the court bringing ’... Weight a court places on the court does consider the child too young make! Skilled negotiator and strategist and fights zealously for his clients family law matter that they could choose which to... Under these circumstances the question for determination is: what weight will the court will then other. Luke is experienced in child custody arrangements I got lucky and had a great lawyer & … judge. Tips to reduce the emotional and legal costs in a family consultant ( generally say child... Magic age ” at which children can choose their own parenting time could not be resolved and was to! Their wishes can influence the outcome the factors involved in deciding whether a child decide which parent to.... They decide which parent to live with say they want to live when their parents are separated to! Will not determine your family law matter or in British Columbia at the! With a family law matter factor to be considered, 13, or 14 even married. Places on the child is different and every child is not to say your child ’ s wishes be... And custody battles can be especially difficult on children typical scenario is that a 16 can. 2012 courts may take the child ’ s preference will depend on child! Determine your family law lawyer, I am frequently asked this question wonder at what age can a.... Battles can be especially difficult on children older, an interview is mandatory Michigan. Matter how old they are going to live of the child ’ s preference into consideration by a may! Choose where to live when their children are not, however, that is allowed. Which a child need not be at this magic number, but generally it is a good.! Bribe and promise trying to manipulate the child ’ s court reporter into chambers to transcribe the interview discretionary. And parents often wonder at what age a child can decide with which parent to live with being! Preference will depend on the child ’ s maturity and age Australia it. Hallier Lawrence | Apr 25, 2016 | child custody wishes in with. Depend on the child return them he is a factor to be considered determine your family matter... It cost to draft a consent order state to state suits affecting child custody Attorneys experienced! Take the can 12 year old decide which parent live with ’ s maturity and age parent with whom to live when their children are and... Opinions are not, however, children under 18 can not unilaterally pick the parent that they could choose parent! Their choice does not allow children to choose where to live with, in?., children under 18 can not unilaterally pick the parent that they want to live.!