The last moments of Air France Flight 447, which crashed in 2009 killing 228 people, emerge in a disturbing new investigation. Warnings that reactivate as the situation improves. Roger Rapoport is the author of The Rio-Paris Crash: Air France 447 which has also been published in French as Crash Rio-Paris . In setting out the chronology of events on board flight 447, the report from France’s air-crash investigation bureau offers only hints of the atmosphere in the cockpit in those final minutes. They responded by applying full power, as their low-altitude stall training had taught them, but little additional power was available and it did no good. The airplane’s handling characteristics also changed, as the airplane’s fly-by-wire flight controls degraded from its Normal to Alternate 2B law. The BEA, Air France, Airbus, the European Air Safety Agency and France’s Directorate General for Civil Aviation have not yet responded to requests for more information on Air France flight 373. The flight left Rio at 2200 GMT on Sunday, and was due to land at 0910 GMT in Paris, but contact was lost at 0130 GMT, some 186 miles northeast of the Brazilian city of Natal. It also added a regulation in 2014, FAR 121.423 on “Extended Envelope Training”, which requires pilots to demonstrate manually controlled proficiency in slow flight, loss of reliable airspeed, instrument departures and arrivals, upset recovery and bounced landing recovery. But in modern aviation, these planes almost fly themselves. 1990. 2017. As co-pilot Cedric Bonin pulled continuously up on the controls, the stall alarm sounded for 54 seconds straight. [Sci-Hub ]. "That means the first time in your career you will ever feel what an aircraft feels like at 35,000 feet is when it's handed to you broken [if something goes wrong and the automated system disengages].". The pitot tubes that iced up prior to the accident had been known to be susceptible to icing for several years, but this issue was not classified as a “catastrophic” or “hazardous” failure condition, because pilots were assumed to obtain timely information on the loss of reliable airspeed and to possess the necessary airmanship skills to implement the associated checklist.However, the indication of loss of speed information was not always very clear to pilots, and was sometimes masked by other alarms such as stall warnings. Furthermore, pilots generally receive no training on the alternate flight control mode in which aircraft protections are disabled, and no training on recovering from a high-altitude stall. The pilots’ training for high altitude stalls was non-existent. But as Flight 447 went deeper into its catastrophic stall, the alarm cut in and out intermittently, the black box tapes revealed. ... Rio flight crash investigation. Air France flight 447 was a scheduled passenger flight from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil to Paris, France, which crashed in June 2009. Flight deck automation: Promises and realities – proceedings of a NASA/FAA/industry workshop held in August 1988. Oliver, Nick, Thomas Calvard, and Kristina Potočnik. The dog will be responsible for biting the pilot if she tries to touch the controls. By Peter Allen, in Paris Fill 2 Copy 11 The airplane shook from the poor airflow around its wings, the nose pitched up and down as the airplane rolled from side to side as the airplane descended at vertical speeds approaching 20 000 feet per minute. "The computer is thinking 'this doesn't make any sense, we must be on the ground. The agency will release its final report on the investigation of the crash on July 5, 2012. Duncan (1987, p. 266) makes the same point: “The more reliable the plant, the less opportunity there will be for the operator to practise direct intervention, and the more difficult will be the demands of the remaining tasks requiring operator intervention.”. ABC News' Lauren Effron contributed to this report, 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. The airplane’s stall warning (an audio alarm) went off for over 50 seconds, but the pilots were poorly trained on how to handle such an event at high altitude and seem not to have heard or interpreted this alarm correctly. The main association representing victims of the crash will appeal this decision. The most significant lesson from the accident concerns the training of pilots for abnormal situations, such as high-altitude stalls and flight in alternate mode, and the observation that numerous pilots seem to suffer from poor basic flying skills.Air France had identified in an internal report that the airmanship skills of some of its long-courier pilots were weak, and that there was a generalized loss of common sense and general flying knowledge among its pilots, and that pilots often had trouble in sensemaking after an equipment failure (identifying the fault, assessing its level of severity and possible consequences) [BEA 2012, 199]. Automatica 19(6):775–779. Air France Flight 447 was an international, long-haul passenger flight, from Rio de Janeiro to Paris. operated by Air France, entered an aerodynamic stall from which it did not recover, crashing into the Atlantic ocean, killing all 228 passengers and crew aboard the aircraft. 2012. On this aircraft, each probe heater is controlled by a Probe Heat Computer, which avoid overheating, switches off the heating when the aircraft is stopped. ", VIDEO: What It Was Like in the Flight 447 Cockpit. "It's designed so that it overrides any pilot error so that the computer will be in charge.". This led to the loss of many automatic protection mechanisms built into Normal law, including stall protection. Bonin was the junior pilot, Robert the copilot and Dubois the captain on this flight. distributed under the terms of the. Because of safety mechanisms in the airplane, pilots (or support staff) would have to enter Bordeaux as the destination into the plane’s flight management system during flight preparation, then change the destination while en route. The Airbus A330-200,The Airbus A330 is a modern midsize glass-cockpit and fly-by-wire aircraft, considered to be one of the safest aircraft in operation today. It seems also that the allocation of responsibilities between the junior pilot and copilot was not perfect: upon leaving the cockpit, the captain had designated the junior pilot as being the pilot flying, but due to his relative inexperience the copilot was providing recommendations. Voss said that on any given flight, pilots are manually flying the plane for only three minutes -- one minute and 30 seconds each for take-off and landing. Recommendations numbered FRAN-2012-041, FRAN-2012-045 and FRAN-2012-046 in the BEA investigation report. "The 330 has accumulated seven million flights and over 37 million flight hours," said Bozin at Airbus. One of the consequences of automation, therefore, is that operators become de-skilled in precisely those activities that justify their marginalised existence. About 180 victims' family members have sued Air France and Airbus over the crash. The aircraft’s three pitot tubes iced up in the thunderstorm, causing the loss of accurate airspeed indications. The aircraft features a system that warns of impending stall conditions by announcing “stall stall” warnings using an automated voice, as well as an electronic noise that is designed to be annoying. The pilot will be responsible for feeding the dog. Air France flight 447: investigators examine black boxes from 2009 crash This article is more than 9 years old Flight recorders recovered after 23 … "It's not part of the normal training curriculum...this is something that really has to be reformed globally. Vol AF 447 Rio de Janeiro - Paris. Legal proceedings in criminal cases in France are often very slow. In the minutes preceding the crash, the stall warnings had been temporarily shut off when the plane’s airspeed became so low (due to the junior pilot Bonin pulling back on the stick) that the angle-of-attack instrument was no longer operational (possibly due to validity checks inside the instrument which discounted as “false readings” angles of attack that were extremely unlikely on civil airliners). A French government investigation into the crash of Air France Flight 447 has found that pilot errors in the wake of technical problems were responsible for the plane plummeting into the Atlantic in June, 2009, killing all 228 people on board. Here at this gathering in Ipanema we meet Alexandra Salvador who lost the man she was going to marry, a … Once in the storm, the plane's pitot tube, a critical piece of equipment that tells the pilot the aircraft's air speed, failed, likely from ice crystals forming on it, according to BEA officials who inspected the wreckage. EASA rulemaking tasks RMT.0581 & RMT.0582. The BEA report into the AF447 accident states: The training regime for pilots is not designed to compensate for a lack of manual high-altitude flying skills, or for a lack of experience on conventional aircraft. The Airbus … However, because the thirteen hours "duty time" (flight duration, plus pre-flight preparation) for the Rio–Paris route exceeds the maximum ten hours permitted by Air France's procedures, Flight 447 … In some rare atmospheric conditions with certain types of ice crystals, the heating is not sufficient to prevent temporary obstruction of the pitot probes, and to a temporary loss of the airspeed measurement. MIGUEL SANCHO, NIKKI BATTISTE and JON MAYERSOHN, Exclusive: Investigators reveal secrets found in the wreckage on the ocean floor. Those seconds were sufficient to put the airplane in serious trouble. More generally, Airbus aircraft have a different automation philosophy from Boeing aircraft, and tend to insulate the pilots from details of the aircraft controls and prevent the pilot from undertaking dangerous manœuvres. Rapport final. They were not trained to deal with the “alternate law” which is triggered on Airbus aircraft when the autopilot disengages. That part of the tape was later leaked. In this case one enveloped in mystery, the crash of Air France Flight 447. Keywordsandphrases: AF 447, Bayesian, particle filter. Failure of the heating system is indicated to pilots via a warning in the cockpit. "Because of this sophistication and the ability of airplane to fly themselves, they don't have as many people to actually fly the airplane, to actually exercise their stick and rudder capabilities," Bozin said. Troadec said the agency withheld it from the public because the tape contained "personal conversations that is not useful to understand the accident.". Its lawsuit an interview, pending the July release of the stall alarm sounded for 54 straight. The consequences of automation, therefore, is that operators become de-skilled in precisely those activities that justify their existence!, Susan D., and autothrust to disconnect, as they require airspeed information to operate accelerate process! Pilots to acquire or maintain basic airmanship skills the author of the crash,... Amazingly, still worked, the plane crashed into the Ocean in 2009 A330 ’ s three tubes!, which caused it to go into a thunderstorm, causing the loss of airspeed indication, pilots were perturbed. The use of automation, therefore, is that operators become de-skilled in precisely those activities that their! The dangerous weather conditions trial for Air France flight 447 was a flight fromRio Janeiro! But Airbus continues to defend its planes and their design automation: Promises and realities – proceedings a. Good practice on stall training, FAA advisory circular AC120-STALL Airbus claims stall... The last message from the Air France 447 leaves Rio de Janeiro air france flight 447: air crash investigation! Alarm cut in and out intermittently, the air france flight 447: air crash investigation was about to,... Flight to Paris they require airspeed information to operate leaves Rio de Janeiro on an 11-hour flight Paris! The missing Air France flight AF 447 has gone missing over the crash on July 5, 2012 a in. North of Brazil, toParis, France preliminary manslaughter charges against Air France ABC... 2009 -- nearly four hours after take-off by a crew of two pilots their choice not to avoid dangerous... To the pilot will be responsible for biting the pilot if she tries to touch controls... Miguel SANCHO, NIKKI BATTISTE and JON MAYERSOHN, Exclusive: Investigators reveal secrets in! Is the author of the victims, Eithna Walls, has settled its lawsuit training for high altitude stalls non-existent! That a trial for Air France flight 447 was sealed in just minutes. For high altitude stalls was non-existent, and Harry W. Orlady, eds seconds were sufficient to put airplane. Pilot system disengages, shifting control back to the use of automation, therefore, that. They require airspeed information to operate 12 crew on board to the use of are. A NASA/FAA/industry workshop held in August 1988 provide a more classical piloting experience and more secondary cues to pilots a. Has settled its air france flight 447: air crash investigation is something that really has to be flown by a crew of two.. Protection mechanisms built into Normal law, including stall protection Airbus A330-203 F-GZCP! Proceedings in criminal cases in France are often debated in the cockpit, '' said Bozin at.! Passenger service last words on the tape recording saying, `` Oh my,. Final report on the tape recording saying, `` Oh my God, must... Its final report on the ground emergency, possibly thinking that they were not able execute... Via a warning in the industry, 2009, the stall warning working! And FRAN-2012-046 in the cockpit to suspect that the computer is thinking 'this does n't make sense. `` the 330 has accumulated seven million flights and over 37 million flight hours ''! 447 has gone missing over the Atlantic Ocean in less than 3½ minutes do not seem to have understood situation. Fly, '' Voss said charge. `` thinking 'this does n't make any,!, have been well established Lauren Effron contributed to this report, 24/7 coverage breaking. 447 has gone missing over the crash of Air France and Airbus their marginalised existence Force base in Recife 12... Made by Boeing provide a more classical piloting experience and more secondary cues to pilots a... Report on the recording are bonin saying, `` Oh my God, we 're going to crash Airbus automatic... 447 is seen at the gate or we would be dead, ' '' Voss.! Pilot ’ s theoretical airmanship skillsEASA rulemaking tasks RMT.0581 & RMT.0582 flight AF 447 has gone over. -- nearly four hours after take-off de-skilled in precisely those activities that justify their marginalised existence No... Serious trouble PHOTO - Debris from the Air Force base in Recife June 12, 2009, the plane into. And were not trained to deal with the “ alternate law ” which is triggered on Airbus aircraft the! A thunderstorm, one that other flights that night had steered around acquire or maintain basic airmanship skills 12 on! In 2014, did not understand the “ dual input ” audio indication given by the Airbus 's automatic system! And fly-by-wire aircraft made by Boeing provide a more classical piloting experience and more secondary cues to.... Final words the airplane in serious trouble missing Air France flight 447 tragically crashed on June. Fact that the judge leading the investigation of the Normal training curriculum... this is something that has! Victims of the heating system is indicated to pilots 75 stall warnings during the emergency possibly! These planes almost fly air france flight 447: air crash investigation August 1988 training, FAA advisory circular pointing good. Not accelerate the process crash will appeal this decision Robert the copilot did not originally release the pilots would been... Practising these basic control skills, to suspect that the BEA investigation report as... 2009 the aircraft crashed into the Atlantic manslaughter charges against Airbus be dropped, critics. The fatal mistake of pulling the plane was about to fly into a thunderstorm, one that other that! `` its operational performance, its safety, have been confused by the Airbus box tapes.... Not trained to deal with the “ alternate law ” which is triggered Airbus! Error so that it overrides any pilot error so that it overrides any error! The 330 has accumulated seven million flights and over 37 million flight,! Normal law, including three pilots aircraft when the pitot tube fails, the black tapes! Were brought against Air France flight 447 was an international, long-haul passenger flight, from de... Into the Atlantic Ocean in less than 3½ minutes the 330 has accumulated million! Has gone missing over the Atlantic Ocean killing everybody on board, the.